top of page

Is a Pitcher Filter Enough on Daniel Island? Pitchers vs Under-Sink Drinking Water Filters

Christian Devlin
Nov 12
2 min read

Almost every kitchen I walk into on Daniel Island has a filter pitcher in the fridge. That's a good instinct. Most folks just want their drinking water and coffee to taste better than straight from the tap. The question I get is whether the pitcher is doing enough, or whether it's time for something under the sink.

I'm Christian with Avery & Sons Plumbing + Tankless. Here's how I explain it to neighbors.

What a pitcher filter does well

  • Cheap to start. No plumbing, no install, and you can take it with you if you move.

  • Better taste. Most pitchers use loose carbon that knocks down chlorine taste and smell, which is the main complaint on city water around here (more in our chlorine and carbon filter post).

  • Good for renters and small households. If it's one or two people and you mostly drink bottled water away from home, a pitcher can be plenty.

Where pitchers fall short

  • Slow and small. You're waiting on a refill every time you want to cook pasta or fill the coffee maker, so people end up using tap water anyway.

  • Easy to forget the cartridge. Pitcher cartridges are rated for a fairly small number of gallons. Once they're past it, they're not doing much. See how often to change water filters.

  • Limited certifications. Many pitchers are certified only for taste and odor. Some carry health claims like lead reduction, but you have to check the specific model. Our guide to NSF ratings on the filter box walks through how to read them.

  • Cleaning. A pitcher sitting in the fridge needs to be washed regularly, or it can get slimy.

What an under-sink filter changes

An under-sink carbon block filter or reverse osmosis system feeds a dedicated faucet at the kitchen sink. You get filtered water on demand for drinking, cooking, coffee, and pets, with no refilling. Cartridges are larger and usually last months instead of weeks, and there are more models certified for health-related contaminants, not just taste. It does take a little cabinet space, a cold-water connection, and a hole in the sink or countertop for the faucet.

How I'd decide

  • Stick with a pitcher if you're renting, it's a small household, and taste is the only concern.

  • Move to under-sink if you're refilling the pitcher more than once a day, you cook a lot, or you want a filter certified for something specific like lead.

  • Look at whole-house if the chlorine smell bothers you in the shower too, not just at the glass. Our whole-house vs under-sink post covers that choice.

Easy next step

Avery & Sons Plumbing + Tankless installs under-sink filters, reverse osmosis systems, and whole-house filtration across Charleston, Daniel Island, Mount Pleasant, East Cooper, and nearby towns. If you'd like help picking the right setup for your kitchen, call (843) 305-5555 or visit averysplumbing.com.

Neighbors, there's nothing wrong with a pitcher. Just be honest about whether you're actually using it, and whether it's certified for what you care about.

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


Avery & Sons Plumbing + Tankless logo with smiling plumber

460 Seven Farms Drive, Suite 300

Daniel Island, SC 29492

©2022 by Avery & Sons - Plumbing, Tankless, Gas, and Drain.

bottom of page
Text Us
Call Now