top of page

Does a TDS Meter Tell You If Your Water Is Safe on Daniel Island? What That Pen Tester Really Measures

Christian Devlin
2 days ago
3 min read

Every so often a neighbor on Daniel Island hands me a little pen-shaped tester and asks if their water is bad. Sometimes a salesperson dipped it in a glass of tap water, showed them a number, and then pitched a system. Sometimes they bought one online and got worried. Either way, the question is the same: what does that number actually mean?

I'm Christian with Avery & Sons Plumbing + Tankless. Here's the plain version.

What a TDS meter measures

TDS stands for total dissolved solids. A TDS pen doesn't count anything directly. It measures how well the water conducts electricity and converts that into an estimate in parts per million (ppm). Dissolved minerals and salts like calcium, magnesium, sodium, and bicarbonate make water more conductive, so the number goes up when there's more of them in the water.

What it can't tell you

A TDS number is not a safety test. It doesn't detect most of the things people actually worry about:

  • Lead. Lead can be present at levels that matter for health while barely moving a TDS reading. A lab test is the real answer. See our lead in tap water post.

  • PFAS and other chemicals. Many of these don't conduct electricity, so a pen won't see them. More in our PFAS filter guide.

  • Bacteria. A TDS meter can't detect germs at all.

  • Chlorine or chloramine. The disinfectant that gives city water its taste and smell won't show up in a meaningful way.

So a low number doesn't prove water is clean, and a higher number doesn't prove it's unsafe. Mineral-rich water can read higher and be perfectly fine to drink.

Why the salesperson demo is misleading

A common pitch is to test tap water, then test water from their system, and show the number dropping. That mainly shows the system removes minerals. It says nothing about whether your tap water had a problem to begin with. If you're shopping for filtration, look at what the system is actually certified to reduce, which our NSF ratings guide explains.

Softeners and carbon filters barely move it

  • Water softener. A softener swaps hardness minerals for sodium (or potassium), so the water still has dissolved solids in it. Your TDS often stays about the same even when the softener is working perfectly. Here's more on drinking softened water.

  • Carbon filters. Whole-house and under-sink carbon filters target taste, odor, and certain chemicals, not dissolved minerals, so they don't change TDS much either.

If someone tells you your softener or carbon filter is broken because the TDS didn't drop, that's not a fair test.

Where a TDS meter is genuinely useful: reverse osmosis

This is where I actually like these little pens. A reverse osmosis membrane removes most dissolved solids, so a TDS meter is a quick, cheap way to check that it's still doing its job:

  • Test the tap. Run the kitchen cold tap for a bit and take a reading.

  • Test the RO faucet. Take a reading from the RO faucet. It should be much lower than the tap.

  • Write both numbers down. Check again every few months. If the RO reading starts creeping up toward the tap reading, the membrane may be worn out or a seal may be letting water bypass it.

Two notes. If your RO has a remineralization stage, it adds some minerals back on purpose, so the RO reading will be a bit higher than without it. We covered that in our remineralization filter post. And if the RO is also slow, our post on why reverse osmosis slows down walks through what to check.

When to call us

  • Your RO reading is climbing toward your tap reading, even after changing the filters.

  • You want a real water test before buying a softener or filtration system, not just a pen reading.

  • Someone used a TDS demo to sell you a system and you want a second opinion before you sign.

Easy next step

Avery & Sons Plumbing + Tankless installs and services reverse osmosis systems, under-sink filters, whole-house filters, and water softeners across Charleston, Daniel Island, Mount Pleasant, East Cooper, and nearby towns. Call (843) 305-5555 or visit averysplumbing.com.

Neighbors, a TDS pen is a handy tool for checking an RO system. Just don't let anyone use it to scare you into buying one.

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


Avery & Sons Plumbing + Tankless logo with smiling plumber

460 Seven Farms Drive, Suite 300

Daniel Island, SC 29492

©2022 by Avery & Sons - Plumbing, Tankless, Gas, and Drain.

bottom of page
Text Us
Call Now